I replaced the cartridge in a Moen sink faucet a few months back. The setscrew came loose on the handle and it seemed like it was taking more effort to turn side to side, so with the help of my 3 y/o I pulled the whole thing apart today. After putting plumbers grease on the outside of the cartridge and putting everything back together, the handle turns side to side well, but it takes significantly more effort to raise the handle to turn the water on and off.

What did I do wrong?